Apple MacBook Pro 17inch 2.8GHz Review

SEE IT
Apple MacBook Pro 17inch 2.8GHz
1,500 £ at amazon.co.uk
  • Intel Core 2 Duo T9600 (2.8 GHz)

  • NVIDIA GeForce 9600M GT

  • 4 GB RAM Size

  • 500 GB HDD Capacity

2

Our summary of all reviews

  • Performance

    36 /100

    This high level of performance allows for regular office work, multitasking, multimedia and HD video applications to run at a high speed. This laptop is adequate for professional video editing and other high performance tasks. It also supports quite well games such as “Call of Duty 4”. This laptop is ideal for users who demand high speed performance.

    • 3DMark 06 1024 x 768

      6104 #

    • 3DMark Vantage

      1703 #

    • PCMark 05

      7928.67 #

    • PCMark Vantage

      3940.4 #

    • Cinebench xCPU 64Bit

      5546 #

    ▼ expand ▲ collapse
  • Design

    4.7/5

    The laptop design was received with great enthusiasm by reviewers. The crushing majority agrees that even people with the highest sense of aesthetics will be ecstatically pleased.

  • Build Quality

    4.8/5

    The extremely solid build quality provides for absolute protection of the inner components of this laptop. All the outer components -hinge, display panel, and chassis- are highly stable, with no gaps or cracking sounds ever experienced. This computer is ideal for people with very active lifestyles, requiring absolute endurance and solidity of their laptops.

    • Base Unit Flex

       : 

      4.7/5

      Active people with lifestyles requiring traveling, and who place a high value on perfection will be very satisfied with this laptop.

    • Hinge Stability

       : 

      4.7/5

      The hinge, connecting the screen and the laptop frame, has a great balance between tightness and flexibility. It allows for a smooth use without experiencing any cracking sounds or stiffness when moving around. The display does not suffer from any shakiness and yet you can open it easily with one hand.

    • Display Panel

       : 

      4.0/5

      Colour distortions barely visible to the naked eye occur when pressing the back of the monitor, or when moving it back and forth. The user can expect that no gaps will exist between the different parts of the display panel.

    ▼ expand ▲ collapse
  • Display

    4.4/5

    The monitor provides good potential for professional designers and photographers. Gaming and multimedia users will be satisfied with this display. Looking at the screen both indoors and outdoors is a generally enjoyable experience. Therefore, even demanding business users will be satisfied with this great display.

    • Display Resolution

      1920 x 1200

      This high resolution enables the user to multitask and is as well quite handy for all sorts of office work. The vast screen estate allows for two websites to be viewed side by side. Movie and picture editors as well as graphic designers will be able to carry out tasks demanding high resolution comfortably. Users however should be aware that when viewing most movies, black bars at the top and the bottom of the picture will constantly be on the monitor. Gaming will only be possible if the computer has the most powerful graphic card supporting this high resolution.

    • Color Reproduction

       : 

      4.5/5

      This computer features perfect color reproduction. The color spectrum is fully covered, thus the colors are both attractive and true to nature. The screen fulfills the needs of professional designers as it displays the full sRGB spectrum. It as well is very attractive to non-professional users and gamers, because the picture is realistic and is thus perfect for high resolution games and HD movies for example.

    • Contrast

       : 

      4.5/5

      This laptop is able to produce a sharp contrast between the darkest color -black- and the brightest color -white-. This contrast ratio allows comfortable reading even when exposed to a bright ambient light. This feature is thus attractive to outdoor users, and office workers. Professional designers, gamers and movie viewers will as well be completely satisfied with this contrast. Shadows are so perfectly displayed that two-dimensional images appear almost three-dimensional. Movies using shadow effects extensively, like Horror, Mystery or Action movies, will be a delight to watch on this notebook. This contrast is especially appreciated with small-sized screens.

    • Contrast Value

      548.67 :1

    • Brightness

       : 

      4.3/5

      Setting the computer to its maximum brightness will allow you to see the screen even when a strong light is shining on it. Outdoor usability is enhanced with this level of display brightness. Under most indoor light settings however, the screen would be too bright and should be dimmed for comfortable use. Making the display darker has the additional benefit of greatly increasing the battery life. The laptop brightness is evenly distributed over the whole screen, meaning the brightness is not concentrated on one spot of the monitor.

    • Average Brightness

      264.22 cd/m²

    • Reflections

       : 

      2.0/5

      In situations of medium indoor ambient light, the display can sufficiently fulfill its function. This laptop is thus acceptable for office work, and can serve as well as a family/home computer. Outdoor use is however not recommended, as it will be close to impossible to decipher the displayed information.

    • Viewing Angle

       : 

      4.0/5

      You can see the screen comfortably even when looking from the side. Colors distortions will only happen, when the display is leaned backward or forward to its maximum. You can comfortably watch a movie with friends, or show the screen to a few people.

    ▼ expand ▲ collapse
  • Sound

    3.5/5

    The sound quality of this laptop is average compared to other notebooks. Although these internal speakers are adequate for easy listening, you should not count on them for a fun movie night with friends. Gaming could still be fairly enjoyed, but the user should always account for external speakers or headphones for a better sound experience.

    • Maximum Volume

       : 

      4.5/5

      The peak volume of this laptop allows the user to enjoy loud music completely filling the room. Action and thriller movies will be very much enjoyed at maximum volume, with no external speakers required. Sensitive souls should refrain from watching horror movies at maximum volumes, your heart might stop beating. Although this maximum volume ranks among the best for laptops, it will still not fulfil the demands of audiophiles.

    • Sound Clarity

       : 

      4.0/5

      The sound is quite clear. Background noises should be no issue. This computer provides for an enjoyable sound experience when watching movies and playing games.

    • Lows

       : 

      3.0/5

      The bass in this laptop provides relative support for the overall sound experience. Most users might still find the bass acceptable, although this greatly depends on their expectations. Sound effects that depend on bass, like explosions in movies and games will not sound very convincing.

    ▼ expand ▲ collapse
  • Keyboard

    3.6/5

    This keyboard will be valued by most users as convenient for frequent use. Be it for writing long emails, or surfing the net, most users will be satisfied with the comfort and the speed this keyboard provides for. If your professional life requires long typing hours, along with the highest levels of comfort, then you might want to consider a keyboard with higher rates.

    • Layout

       : 

      3.0/5

      The layout of this keyboard might not feel comfortable for everyone. Inconveniences such as unintuitive positioning of different keys and different key sizes compared to the standard layout will be encountered. This most likely will lead to typing errors until the user readjusts to the keyboard.

    • Keyboard Size

       : 

      5.0/5

      This keyboard is characterized by large keys, thus dramatically reducing the frequency of typing mistakes. Typing is as well made very comfortable thanks to the deep palm resting area, which is as well handy when playing games, or for any activity requiring long hours of commitment. The whole keyboard is well proportionate with just the right spacing between the keys, providing for an ideal size for most users.

    • Key Responsiveness

       : 

      3.3/5

      The responsiveness of this keyboard allows for most users to be satisfied with individual key feedback. The keys do require some pressure for efficient typing, without being either too soft or too stiff for manipulation. Most users will find this keyboard supportive for long typing hours as the keys can be pressed down without any difficulty and they respond back quite fast. Although this keyboard might not be responsive enough for some, the general feel of the keyboard should be within the ranges of satisfaction for most of us.

    • Keyboard Flex

       : 

      5.0/5

      The users will be happy to find that this keyboard is sturdy and very reliable. The keyboard does not bend at all even under heavy typing or when forcefully pressed. The flex thus is practically non-existent, making the typing experience not only enjoyable, but as well fast and comfortable.

    • Keys Clicking Sound

       : 

      5.0/5

      Using this keyboard will not cause any disturbance noise wise. Clicking an individual key provides for an unobtrusive feedback fitting the quietest surroundings. In short: A nice recurring easy-to-get-used-to sound.

    ▼ expand ▲ collapse
  • Touchpad

    4.5/5

    The reviewers found this trackpad to provide for a perfect combination of size, accuracy, smoothness and resistance. All these qualities make this trackpad a perfect fit for laptops with big displays, or everyone who plans to use the touchpad extensively only for gaming you will find an external mouse needed. The buttons are as well suited for all applications even those requiring a high level of accuracy such as picture editing or design. In short, this trackpad will ease you into adapting to your laptop in quite a pleasing way.

    • Touchpad Surface

       : 

      5.0/5

      The touchpad surface of this keyboard is nothing short of perfect. The manufacturer has managed to keep the tricky balance of smoothness and resistance. The touchpad feels great, accommodating for users requiring either relative roughness against sweaty finger, or smoothness to help with sliding across the screen. No matter your needs, this surface will not disappoint you.

    • Sensitivity

       : 

      5.0/5

      This touchpad has proved to provided for excellent feedback with impressive accuracy. There was no lag or jumpiness, which greatly contributes to increasing your working speed. Your mouse pointer’s precision will be nothing short of an arrow splitting the stem of a flower. All in all, this touchpad is perfectly reliable concerning precision and reaction.

    • Touchpad Size

       : 

      5.0/5

      The generous size of this touchpad will remind of limitless playing fields when you were a little child. You can reach the furthest part on the screen with a single slide over the touchpad, even with big displays.

    • Buttons

       : 

      2.8/5

      The reviewers considered the quality of this trackpad button to be less than average. Although this button quality might be sufficient for some, it will be less than desired for most. Problems with the unclear feedback, excessive softness or stiffness of the button will be obstacles for efficient use. The clicking sound produced by this button might as well be a little too obtrusive for pleasant use.

    ▼ expand ▲ collapse
  • Webcam Quality

    2.0/5

    The picture can be a little bit noisy when the light conditions are not good but for video chatting it will be okay.

  • Battery Surfing

    6:49 h

    The battery life is outstanding. You will be able to use your laptop for the better part of a whole work day. This of course requires you to turn down the brightness of your screen, as the display uses a lot of energy. You should also only plan to do office work and light browsing. If you are going to play games, stream videos, or surf websites with a lot of flash advertisement, the expected battery life will be considerably shorter. The energy saving mode should be enabled at all times, if not this will of course cause the battery life to drop even shorter.

    • Battery DVD/Video

      4:38 h

      When performing energy consuming tasks, this battery will last from 4 to 5 hours. Be it for watching a couple of movies, preparing presentations, or streaming videos, this battery will not fail you for quite some time. Note: Gaming requires much more power thus you will only be able to enjoy it for a much more limited time.

    ▼ expand ▲ collapse
  • Weight

    2.99 kg

    Some users will be exhausted carrying the computer with them, even for a few minutes. Although the weight is within the range of acceptability, it might yet be challenging to find a fitting bag for comfortable mobility. If you take into account the extra weight of the charger, this notebook will be tiring to walk around with even for a short period of time. It might as well occupy too much space for convenient use in cafes or airplanes.

  • Noise

    3.2/5

    Most users will find the laptop to be on the quiet side. There is some noise emitted from the fan, the CD drive and other laptop parts, yet most will not experience any inconveniences due to it. Noise sensitive people might opt for an even quieter computer.

    • Noise Idle

       : 

      4.0/5

      Normally you do not notice the noise of the laptop ventilation while idle.

    • Noise Normal Use

       : 

      3.0/5

      Noise emitted from this laptop will not cause any major inconveniences when doing office work or browsing the Internet. Although it might be be noticeable in a quite room, it should not be obstructing your concentration.

    • Noise Full Load

       : 

      2.0/5

      The notebook can get quite loud when watching movies, editing videos, playing games or any other kind of performance demanding application. If you are in a quiet environment, you might want to avoid running such high performance applications to avoid annoying the people around you.

    ▼ expand ▲ collapse
  • Temperature

    2.1/5

    The laptop often gets too warm. Most reviewers found, at normal room temperature, it may be okay to keep the notebook on your lap when you are just surfing the net. The laptop will definitely get hot when you stress it, watching a movie or alike.

    • Heat Top: Full Use

       : 

      4.5/5

      The laptop keeps quite cool at normal use. That’s very convenient.

    • Heat Top: Normal Use

       : 

      2.3/5

      The notebook can get a little bit warmer on top.

    • Heat Bottom: Normal Use

       : 

      2.0/5

      The bottom of the laptop can get a bit warmer. If you don’t want to use it on your lap, it will be okay.

    • Heat Bottom: Full Load

       : 

      1.3/5

      There are unpleasant hot spots on the laptop.

    ▼ expand ▲ collapse
4

Where to buy

You can get the Apple MacBook Pro 17inch 2.8GHz for 1,500£
A

All external reviews  Apple  MacBook Pro 17inch 2.8GHz

Language Source URL Review Date Author

English

www.eweek.com 4/29/09 Cameron Sturdevant

English

www.slashgear.com 4/28/09 Vincent Nguyen & Chris Davies

English

www.notebookcheck.com 4/18/09 Klaus Hinum

English

www.itpro.co.uk 4/3/09 Mike Jennings

English

www.techradar.com 3/27/09 Ian Osborne

English

www.hardwarezone.com 3/19/09 Aloysius Low

English

www.digitalartsonline.co.uk 3/17/09 Neil Bennett

English

compreviews.about.com 3/9/09 Mark Kyrnin

English

www.pcadvisor.co.uk 3/6/09 Mark Hattersley & James Galbraith

English

www.reghardware.co.uk 3/6/09 Stephen Dean

English

www.engadget.com 3/4/09 Joshua Topolsky

English

reviews.cnet.co.uk 3/3/09 Dan Ackerman

English

computershopper.com 3/1/09 Jonathan Rougeot

English

www.pcmag.com 2/26/09 Cisco Cheng

Deutsch

www.tomshardware.de 4/24/09 Benjamin Kraft

Deutsch

www.notebookjournal.de 4/4/09 Stefan Trunzik

Deutsch

www.macwelt.de 3/16/09 Christian Möller
▼ expand ▲ collapse
Total number of reviews: 17